Care FeesWillsAssessing Care Fees: What is Deliberate Deprivation?

24 April 2020by Chris Smith3
https://www.willpack.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Assessing-Care-Fees-What-is-Deliberate-Deprivation.jpg

If a person goes into residential care, their local authority will need to carry out a financial assessment to determine how much that person can contribute towards their care home fees. This is known as the means test. A person may attempt to reduce the assets that they own that could contribute towards their care fees, however it should be noted that this could be seen as deliberate deprivation by the local authority and could have consequences.

What is deprivation?

Deprivation is when a person has decreased their assets in order to reduce how much they could contribute towards their own care. Deprivation could be by:

  • Making gifts.
  • Putting assets into trust.
  • Paying off someone’s debts.
  • Converting assets into disregarded assets, for example converting cash into chattels. See our previous article for more information on disregarded capital.
  • Selling an asset for under its value.

In most cases, deprivation will be considering deprivation of capital, however it is also possible for deprivation of income, for example if a person gives or sells the right to income from an occupational pension.

When is deprivation deliberate?

In order for deprivation to be treated as deliberate, the intention to avoid care fees must have been the person’s significant or only factor for the deprivation. Along with this, it must also be proven that the person had a reasonable expectation that they would need care and support at the time of the deprivation. Finally, local authorities will also need to consider if the person had a reasonable expectation of needing to contribute towards the cost of their care needs.

Consequences of deliberate deprivation?

If a local authority decides that a person has committed deliberate deprivation, for the purposes of the financial assessment they can decide to treat the person as if they still own that asset. This is known as notional capital and income.

If assets have been transferred to a third party, they may be liable to pay the difference between what would have been charged and what was charged at the time of the assessment. Where multiple third parties are involved, each will not be liable for any more than their proportion. The local authority may use the County Court to recover unpaid debts but should only do this after they have used all other reasonable options.

3 comments

  • Nigel Evans

    24 April 2020 at 10:34 am

    The creation of a protective property trust on main residence remains outside of deliberate deprivation I assume??

    Reply

    • Chris Smith

      24 April 2020 at 10:50 am

      Hi Nigel

      Using PPTs in the will remains outside of the deliberate deprivation rules as the rules only relate to a person intending to avoid paying for their own care. A PPT has no effect during lifetime and only takes effect on death. Making gifts to a trust on your death to protect your assets from someone else’s care after you have died is not included as deliberate deprivation of assets.

      Reply

  • David Heilbronn

    29 April 2020 at 11:55 am

    As I understand things, a home protection trust or an asset protection trust does protect against long term care fees? It is common knowledge that these trusts in the main are created to avoid care fees even though they protect against other issues such as side ways inheritance etc. also probate is avoided. In my experience not every professional agrees with these trusts as they are considered just to be a legal route to avoid care fees, therefore they do not promote them or produce them as it is with myself.
    Since we are advised that the local authority are likely to challenge any will that appears to be created with an intention to avoid care fees including trusts and we are advised at the point of sale not to deem the trusts to be guaranteed, then where is the creditability? Also, the level of fees charged for these trusts are very high, between £5000-£9000.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

OFFICE
Chancery House
Whisby Way
Lincoln
LN6 3LQ
PHONE
01522 697007

WillPack© Trust Wills & Probate Limited t/a WillPack. All rights reserved.
Registered office: Eclipse House, Whisby Way, Lincoln, LN6 3LQ.
Registered in England and Wales No. 06540022.
Registered with the ICO (Data Protection) No. Z1992110.